Restaurants in Fire Island 24 Restaurants in Fire Island Fire Island SearchAll (165)Restaurants (24)Bars & nightlife (10)Hotels & lodging (19)Parks & nature (10)Government Offices (3)Fire Stations (3)Urgent Care & Emergency Centers (1)Churches & Places of Worship (3)Civic & Community Organizations (2)Real Estate Offices (6)Performing Arts & Event Venues (2)Museums (1)Historical Sites (4)Beaches & piers (23)Golf Courses & Country Clubs (1)Marinas (5)Fitness & Recreation Centers (2)Convenience Stores (2)Grocery & food markets (10)Clothing & Apparel Stores (4)Sporting Goods Stores (2)Gift & Souvenir Shops (1)Event Venues & Spaces (3)Propane Tank Exchange (2)Print Shops & Printing Services (1)Canteen Restaurants41 Picketty Ruff WalkCaptain Bills Restaurant RestaurantsCasino Cafe Fire Island Restaurants3 Trustees WalkCherry Grove Pizza Restaurants179 Ocean WalkDive Restaurants1 Bay WalkDunkin' Restaurants165 W Main StFloyd's Restaurants156 Bayview WalkFlynn's Fire Island Restaurants1 Cayuga StKismet Coffee Company Restaurants21 E. Lighthouse WalkKismet Inn Restaurants1 Oak StKoi Sushi Restaurants136 Main StLe Dock Restaurants60 Bay WalkPines Pizza Restaurants36 Fire Island BlvdPizza Shack of Kismet Restaurants110 E Lighthouse WalkSand Castle Restaurants106 Lewis WalkSayville Donut Group Inc Restaurants165 W Main StSchooner Inn Restaurants57 Bay View WalkSurf's Out Restaurants1 Bay WalkSweet Licks Ice Cream Restaurants180 Bayview WalkThe Blue Whale Restaurants42 Harbor WalkThe Pier At Watch Hill RestaurantsTrustees WalkTiki Joe's Smith Point Restaurants1 William Floyd PkwyTop of the Bay Bistro Restaurants1 Dock WalkUnfriendly's Ice Cream Restaurants21 Broadway