Hotels & lodging in Fire Island 19 Hotels & lodging in Fire Island Fire Island SearchAll (165)Restaurants (24)Bars & nightlife (10)Hotels & lodging (19)Parks & nature (10)Government Offices (3)Fire Stations (3)Urgent Care & Emergency Centers (1)Churches & Places of Worship (3)Civic & Community Organizations (2)Real Estate Offices (6)Performing Arts & Event Venues (2)Museums (1)Historical Sites (4)Beaches & piers (23)Golf Courses & Country Clubs (1)Marinas (5)Fitness & Recreation Centers (2)Convenience Stores (2)Grocery & food markets (10)Clothing & Apparel Stores (4)Sporting Goods Stores (2)Gift & Souvenir Shops (1)Event Venues & Spaces (3)Propane Tank Exchange (2)Print Shops & Printing Services (1)Belvedere Guest House for Men Hotels & lodging33 Bayview WalkBig Dick's Halfway Inn Hotels & lodging188 Holly WalkCarrington House Hotels & lodgingLewis WalkDune Point Hotels & lodging134 Lewis WalkFire Island Beach House Hotels & lodging25 Cayuga StFire Island Boatel Hotels & lodging110 E Lighthouse WalkGrove Hotel Hotels & lodging1 Ocean WalkGrove Hotel & Ice Palace Hotels & lodging67 Bay WalkHarmony in The Pines Hotels & lodging77 Bay WalkMargarita Villas Hotels & lodging177 Pine StOak and Ocean Hotels & lodging144 Ocean WalkPines Bluff Overlook Hotels & lodging362 Ocean WalkPines Camp Hotels & lodging451 Ocean WalkPining Hotels & lodging357 Crown WalkReflections Hotels & lodging73 Bay WalkSeashore Condo Hotel Hotels & lodging78 Bayview WalkThe Green Door, Cherry Grove, Fire Island Hotels & lodging7 Ivy AveThe Grove Hotel Hotels & lodging1 Ocean WalkThe Madison Fire Island Pines Hotels & lodging22 Atlantic Walk