Restaurants in Eagle Bay 6 Restaurants in Eagle Bay Eagle Bay SearchAll (14)Restaurants (6)Hotels & lodging (2)Fire Stations (1)Florists (1)Car & vehicle dealers (1)The Bay Cafe And Market Restaurants5561 NY-28The Donut Shop RestaurantsRT 28The Eagle Bay House Restaurants5521 NY-28The Tavern Restaurants5520 State Route 28Twisters Ice Cream Restaurants5556 NY-28Up North Wood Fire Bar & Grill Restaurants5561 NY-28