Convenience Stores in Otter Creek 2 Convenience Stores in Otter Creek Otter Creek SearchAll (11)Hotels & lodging (2)City Halls & Executive Offices (1)Government Offices (1)Schools (K-12) (1)Churches & Places of Worship (2)Convenience Stores (2)Hershel's Quick Stop Convenience Stores190 SE US Highway 19Otter Creek Country Store Convenience Stores230 SE US Highway 19